Codex sessions do not mount required gitea-workflow skill #551

New Issue

2026-07-08T14:26:36-05:00

jcwalker3 commented

2026-07-08 14:26:36 -05:00

Codex Gitea-Tools author/reviewer tasks require gitea-workflow, but current Codex sessions do not expose that skill.

Observed:

~/.claude/skills/gitea-workflow/SKILL.md exists.
~/.codex/skills does not contain gitea-workflow.
Repo contains skills/llm-project-workflow/SKILL.md and canonical workflow files, but they are not mounted as Codex skills.
mcp_list_project_skills exposes operational guides such as gitea-pr-creation, gitea-pr-review, gitea-issue-comments, gitea-resolve-task-capability, and redaction-security-review, but not gitea-workflow, git-pr-workflows, or llm-project-workflow.
Controller prompts requiring gitea-workflow therefore block in Codex even when Gitea MCP author/reviewer profiles are healthy.

Impact:

PR #545 finalization is blocked in Codex even though the author profile is healthy.
Sessions may incorrectly proceed without the required workflow wall.
Different LLM runtimes now have different workflow skill names/mounts, creating inconsistent behavior and unsafe fallback pressure.

Expected:

Codex sessions for Gitea-Tools can invoke the required workflow skill by exact name, or controller prompts and MCP skill inventory use the same exact canonical name.
If the checked-in skills/llm-project-workflow is the portable replacement, it should be mounted and discoverable under a stable canonical name.
Missing workflow skill should fail clearly during preflight before any Gitea mutation or git mutation is attempted.

Suggested fix:

Install or symlink the workflow skill into ~/.codex/skills/gitea-workflow, or mount the checked-in skills/llm-project-workflow as a Codex skill and update controller prompts accordingly.
Update mcp_list_project_skills so the control plane exposes the same canonical workflow name used in prompts.
Add a preflight that fails clearly when the required workflow skill is missing.
Add tests or proof docs showing Claude/Codex/Gemini sessions resolve the same canonical workflow skill name.

Acceptance criteria:

A Codex session can invoke the required workflow skill by the canonical name.
mcp_list_project_skills includes the canonical workflow skill/router.
Controller prompts no longer reference a skill name unavailable to Codex.
Missing-skill sessions stop before git/Gitea mutation and return a clear BLOCKED reason.
PR #545 can resume only after either the skill is available or a controller explicitly authorizes the checked-in workflow-doc fallback.

Codex Gitea-Tools author/reviewer tasks require `gitea-workflow`, but current Codex sessions do not expose that skill. Observed: - `~/.claude/skills/gitea-workflow/SKILL.md` exists. - `~/.codex/skills` does not contain `gitea-workflow`. - Repo contains `skills/llm-project-workflow/SKILL.md` and canonical workflow files, but they are not mounted as Codex skills. - `mcp_list_project_skills` exposes operational guides such as `gitea-pr-creation`, `gitea-pr-review`, `gitea-issue-comments`, `gitea-resolve-task-capability`, and `redaction-security-review`, but not `gitea-workflow`, `git-pr-workflows`, or `llm-project-workflow`. - Controller prompts requiring `gitea-workflow` therefore block in Codex even when Gitea MCP author/reviewer profiles are healthy. Impact: - PR #545 finalization is blocked in Codex even though the author profile is healthy. - Sessions may incorrectly proceed without the required workflow wall. - Different LLM runtimes now have different workflow skill names/mounts, creating inconsistent behavior and unsafe fallback pressure. Expected: - Codex sessions for Gitea-Tools can invoke the required workflow skill by exact name, or controller prompts and MCP skill inventory use the same exact canonical name. - If the checked-in `skills/llm-project-workflow` is the portable replacement, it should be mounted and discoverable under a stable canonical name. - Missing workflow skill should fail clearly during preflight before any Gitea mutation or git mutation is attempted. Suggested fix: - Install or symlink the workflow skill into `~/.codex/skills/gitea-workflow`, or mount the checked-in `skills/llm-project-workflow` as a Codex skill and update controller prompts accordingly. - Update `mcp_list_project_skills` so the control plane exposes the same canonical workflow name used in prompts. - Add a preflight that fails clearly when the required workflow skill is missing. - Add tests or proof docs showing Claude/Codex/Gemini sessions resolve the same canonical workflow skill name. Acceptance criteria: - A Codex session can invoke the required workflow skill by the canonical name. - `mcp_list_project_skills` includes the canonical workflow skill/router. - Controller prompts no longer reference a skill name unavailable to Codex. - Missing-skill sessions stop before git/Gitea mutation and return a clear BLOCKED reason. - PR #545 can resume only after either the skill is available or a controller explicitly authorizes the checked-in workflow-doc fallback.

jcwalker3 referenced this issue

2026-07-08 14:30:08 -05:00

Require BLOCKED + DIAGNOSE when LLM cannot perform required workflow step #552

jcwalker3 added the status:in-progress label 2026-07-08 21:42:30 -05:00

jcwalker3 commented

2026-07-08 21:42:30 -05:00

Issue claim heartbeat

kind: claim
issue: Codex sessions do not mount required gitea-workflow skill (#551)
branch: feat/issue-551-codex-gitea-workflow
phase: claimed
profile: prgs-author
pr: none
blocker: none
next_action: create worktree and begin implementation

**Issue claim heartbeat** - kind: claim - issue: #551 - branch: feat/issue-551-codex-gitea-workflow - phase: claimed - profile: prgs-author - pr: none - blocker: none - next_action: create worktree and begin implementation

jcwalker3 referenced this issue from a commit

2026-07-08 21:43:51 -05:00

feat: mount canonical gitea-workflow skill for Codex and MCP inventory (Closes #551)

jcwalker3 referenced a pull request that will close this issue

2026-07-08 21:44:01 -05:00

feat: mount canonical gitea-workflow skill for Codex and MCP inventory (Closes #551) #565

sysadmin referenced this issue

2026-07-09 08:13:48 -05:00

feat: mount canonical gitea-workflow skill for Codex and MCP inventory (Closes #551) #565

sysadmin referenced a pull request that will close this issue

2026-07-09 08:14:03 -05:00

feat: mount canonical gitea-workflow skill for Codex and MCP inventory (Closes #551) #565