Adds the durable architecture record epic #631 lacked: layer contract,
authority boundaries, the redaction boundary, /api/v1 versioning with a
compatibility rule for the existing unversioned MVP exports, a target page
map, per-child component ownership for all twenty children (#632-#651),
phase gates, and explicit forbidden paths.
Documentation only. No UI, API, or deployment change.
- docs/architecture/webui-control-plane-console-architecture-adr.md (new)
- docs/webui-local-dev.md: cross-link to the ADR
- tests/test_webui_architecture_docs.py: doc gate for the acceptance
criteria and the cross-link (12 cases)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <[email protected]>
2026-07-22 04:52:21 -05:00
3 changed files with 356 additions and 0 deletions
The MVP web UI shipped under `webui/` as a read-only Starlette application with ten operator routes and a JSON export beside most of them. It is a working foundation, not the console product described by epic #631, and it carries no durable architecture record: no layer contract, no authority boundary, no API versioning rule, no page map, and no statement of which phase may open a write path.
Twenty children (#632–#651) hang off #631. Without one architecture document each implementer re-derives boundaries, and the most likely failure is not a bad view — it is a privileged action wired into the browser before the authorization and audit model of #633 exists.
This ADR is the single retrievable design source for the console. It decides structure only. It implements no UI, no API, and no change to deployment topology.
## 2. Decision summary (core)
| Layer | Owns | Must not |
|-------|------|----------|
| **Browser UI** | Rendering, navigation, operator affordances | Hold tokens, call Gitea/providers directly, or execute an action the server did not gate |
| **HTTP route layer** (`webui/app.py`) | Versioned routing, authentication, authorization, redaction boundary, audit emission | Contain domain logic or reach past a loader to a raw credential |
| **Domain loaders** (`webui/*_loader.py`, `*_scanner.py`, `runtime_health.py`, `project_registry.py`) | Assembling read models from authoritative sources | Mutate anything, or emit unredacted secrets across the boundary |
| **Gitea** | Durable work record: issues, PRs, comments, reviews, labels, merges | Be the concurrency lock under multi-session load |
| **MCP tools / capability gates** | Mutation authorization | Be re-implemented, mirrored, or bypassed by console code |
| **External providers** (Sentry/GlitchTip, AI providers) | Incident and usage data | Assign work or mutate Gitea outside the #612 bridge |
**One-liner:****Gitea records. The DB coordinates. MCP tools authorize. The console projects state and executes only capability-checked, audited actions. Providers observe.**
## 3. Console surface today versus target
`webui/app.py` currently registers these routes (see `../webui-local-dev.md` for the operator-facing table): `/`, `/health`, `/queue`, `/projects`, `/projects/{id}`, `/prompts`, `/runtime`, `/audit`, `/worktrees`, `/leases`, `/actions`, and the unversioned exports `/api/queue`, `/api/projects`, `/api/prompts`, `/api/runtime`, `/api/audit`, `/api/worktrees`, `/api/leases`, `/api/actions`, `/api/actions/{id}/preview`, `/api/actions/{id}/attempt`.
Every one of these is **retained and evolved**. No child issue may recreate a route from scratch; each states in its PR which MVP surface it extends and what it changes.
## 4. Authority boundaries
### 4.1 Gitea (durable record)
Authoritative for issue and PR identity and state, comments, reviews and verdicts, labels, merges, and branch refs. When the console and Gitea disagree about durable state, Gitea wins and the console view is refreshed — never the reverse.
### 4.2 Control-plane DB (coordination)
Authoritative for live coordination: which session holds which assignment or lease, heartbeat freshness, expiry, and the allocation event log. The console reads it; only allocator and lease tools write it.
### 4.3 MCP capability gates (authorization)
`task_capability_map.py` and `gitea_resolve_task_capability` remain the only authority that decides whether a mutation may run. The console asks; it never answers. A console action that cannot name the MCP tool it delegates to is not an action — it is a defect.
### 4.4 Filesystem and git (local state)
Issue lock files, `branches/` worktrees, and registered git worktrees are read through existing scanners. The console never deletes, rebinds, or force-clears local state outside a Phase 2 gated action.
### 4.5 Providers (observe only)
Sentry/GlitchTip and AI providers are read surfaces. The #612 incident bridge is the only path that turns an observation into Gitea work.
Two invariants govern the boundary and are non-negotiable for every child:
1.**No secrets to the browser.** Tokens, keychain identifiers, Authorization headers, raw provider endpoints, and credential-bearing URLs are redacted by default, consistent with `../safety-model.md` §3 and `../credential-isolation.md`. Serializers redact; templates do not sanitize after the fact.
2.**No ungated mutations.** A write reaches an authoritative system only by delegating to an MCP tool that passed its own capability gate. HTML forms and JSON endpoints are transport, never authority.
## 6. API naming and versioning
**Decision:** all console APIs added from Phase 1 onward are served under `/api/v1/...`.
- Nouns are plural and hierarchical: `/api/v1/inventory/leases`, `/api/v1/system/health`.
- Read endpoints are `GET` and side-effect free.
- Phase 2 action endpoints are `POST /api/v1/actions/{action_id}/preview` and `POST /api/v1/actions/{action_id}/execute`; `preview` stays side-effect free and returns a mutation ledger.
- The existing unversioned MVP exports remain as **compatibility aliases** for the whole of Phase 1 so the current operator flow never breaks. They may be retired no earlier than Phase 2, and only after the replacing `v1` route ships and `../webui-local-dev.md` records the swap.
- A breaking change to a `v1` payload requires `/api/v2/...`, not an in-place edit.
- Every JSON payload carries enough provenance for an auditor to tell where the data came from — at minimum the source system and whether the inventory was complete, matching the pagination-proof habit the MVP queue export already established.
| #651 | Model usage, token cost, latency, workflow analytics | analytics component over the event model | 4 |
Related but **outside** this epic: #667 (restart status, impact preview, and approval controls) belongs to the #655 restart-governance umbrella and must reuse the #642 action class rather than adding a second restart surface.
## 9. Phase gates
| Phase | May ship | Entry condition |
|-------|----------|-----------------|
| **1 — read-only visibility** | `GET` pages and `GET /api/v1/...` | this ADR accepted |
| **2 — controlled actions** | gated `POST` action execution | #633 authorization, RBAC, and audit model landed |
| **3 — orchestration and policy** | linkage, policy visibility, versioned policy editing | Phase 1 inventory plus the Phase 2 action framework |
Phase 1 must not open a mutation endpoint, and the read-only guard that returns `405 read-only-mvp` stays in force until the Phase 2 entry condition is met. A phase is not entered by exception; if a control is urgent, the entry condition is what gets prioritized.
## 10. Security and workflow safety
- **Fail closed** on unknown authentication, missing RBAC mapping, or ambiguous lease ownership. An unknown state renders as blocked, never as permitted.
- **Redact by default**, per §5.
- **Every privileged action** requires a resolved capability, an explicit operator confirmation, and a durable audit event naming actor, action, target, and outcome.
- **Contamination surfaces.** Session contamination — including a manually killed MCP daemon (#630) — must be shown and must block clean claims rather than being silently repaired.
- **Deployment boundary unchanged.** Loopback by default, with the existing refusal of public binds (#435). This ADR documents that target; it does not widen it.
## 11. Forbidden paths
These are rejected designs, not preferences:
1.**Raw provider incidents as work.** The allocator never receives an unclassified Sentry/GlitchTip incident; only the #612 bridge turns an observation into a Gitea issue.
2.**Browser-held tokens.** No credential, keychain identifier, or Authorization header is ever sent to the browser or embedded in a client bundle.
3.**Process-kill recovery.** The console must not expose `pkill`, process-identifier termination, or any host process kill as a recovery affordance (#630). Restart is the sanctioned, operator-owned path of #642 and the #655 umbrella.
4.**Ungated browser mutations.** No review, approval, merge, close, or comment may originate from the browser without passing an MCP capability gate.
5.**Policy invented in the console.** The console projects policy from the capability map and canonical workflows; it never encodes a second copy.
6.**Recreating MVP scope.** Re-implementing a #426–#436 surface without an explicit evolve-or-extend statement is out of bounds.
## 12. Approval checklist (readable without chat history)
A controller can accept or reject this ADR against these six points alone:
1. Layers and their owners are defined (§2) and each authority is named (§4).
2. The redaction boundary and the two invariants are stated (§5).
3. API versioning is decided, including what happens to the existing unversioned routes (§6).
4. A page map exists and names an owning child for every page (§7).
5. Every #631 child maps to at least one component and one phase (§8).
6. Phase gates and forbidden paths are explicit (§9, §11).
## 13. Open questions and follow-ups
Unresolved choices are recorded here rather than settled by implication. Each needs its own durable issue before the phase that depends on it:
- **Authentication mechanism.** Whether the console authenticates via an access proxy (Cloudflare Access or equivalent) or an application-level session is deferred to #633. This ADR requires only that it fail closed.
- **Event model substrate.** Whether the #637 timeline reads the control-plane event log directly or through a projection is deferred to #637.
- **CI path filter coverage.** `webui/ci_paths.py` triggers the web UI suite on `webui/`, `tests/test_webui_*`, and `docs/webui*`. This ADR lives under `docs/architecture/`, so editing it alone does not trigger that gate; the accompanying `tests/test_webui_architecture_docs.py` does run in the full suite. Widening the filter is a small follow-up, deliberately not bundled into a documentation-only change.
- **Retention.** Audit-event retention duration is owned by #633.
## 14. Acceptance
Accepting this ADR means:
- Phase 1 children may proceed against the layers, page map, and API rules above.
- Phase 2 children may not open a write path until #633 lands.
- Any deviation is recorded as an amendment to this file with its own issue reference, not as an undocumented divergence in code.
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
sysadmin
jcwalker3andClaude Opus 4.8