Closes#306.
The dedicated reconciler close path (profile, gated close tool, ancestor
proof, tests) already shipped across #301/#304/#309/#310, but the
final-report validator did not require a reconciler close to prove itself.
A handoff could report `PRs closed: #N` while omitting the close
capability, ancestor proof, or linked-issue result and still grade A.
This adds the missing report-time enforcement.
Changes:
- final_report_validator.py — new `reconcile.close_proof_fields` rule
(`_rule_reconcile_close_proof`). Fires only when a PR close is reported
(via the `PRs closed` field or a `reconciler_close_lock`), then blocks
unless the handoff carries close capability proof (gitea.pr.close),
ancestor proof, PR close result, and linked-issue result. Comment-only
and blocked reconciliations are unaffected. New optional
`reconciler_close_lock` kwarg on `assess_final_report_validator`.
- tests/test_final_report_validator.py — TestReconcilerCloseProof (6 cases):
full-proof close passes; missing capability / ancestor / linked-issue
result each block; session close lock requires proof; comment-only
needs no close proof.
- reconcile-landed-pr.md — §18A documents the enforced gate.
Validation:
venv/bin/python -m pytest tests/test_final_report_validator.py \
tests/test_reconciler_close_gate.py tests/test_already_landed_reconcile.py \
tests/test_reconcile_already_landed_pr_tool.py \
tests/test_reconciliation_workflow.py tests/test_review_proofs.py -q
289 passed.
Worktree: branches/issue-306-reconciler-close-proof
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <[email protected]>
Already-landed PR reconciliation could prove a PR should be closed but
stop silently when gitea.pr.close was unavailable, even with comment
capability present. Adopt Option B (comment-then-stop) as the durable
policy and enforce it:
- resolve_partial_reconciliation_plan maps proven capabilities to one
of four outcomes: FULL_RECONCILE_CLOSE_ALLOWED (close_pr proven),
PARTIAL_RECONCILE_COMMENT_THEN_STOP (comment_pr proven, close_pr
missing; one reconciliation comment with PR head SHA, target branch
SHA, ancestor proof, linked issue status, and the missing capability,
then stop), RECOVERY_HANDOFF_ONLY (no comment capability; no Gitea
mutation), and GATE_NOT_PROVEN (no ancestry proof; no mutation
regardless of capability). Missing capability dicts fail closed.
- assess_partial_reconciliation_report requires final reports to
explain why the comment was or was not posted, name the missing
capability, and state the close result or that no mutation ran.
- workflows/reconcile-landed-pr.md gains section 12A documenting the
policy; the workflow contract test locks the new markers.
Tests cover close capability present, close missing with comment
allowed, comment capability missing, all capabilities missing,
unproven ancestry, fail-closed capability dict, and report checks for
each outcome.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <[email protected]>
Consolidate all four canonical workflow files and router SKILL.md:
- review-merge-pr.md (from #334 canonical prompt)
- reconcile-landed-pr.md (reconciliation gates + handoff schema)
- create-issue.md (canonical issue-creation prompt)
- work-issue.md (canonical author/coder prompt)
SKILL.md is now a short router with mode isolation and universal rules.
Adds final-report schemas for all modes and 13 doc-contract tests.
Supersedes partial split work in PR #335; full #333 acceptance in one PR.
sysadminandClaude Opus 4.8